Justin Otto is one of two players in lacrosse program history to earn All-MAAC honors all four years. Otto also garnered MAAC all-tournament team honors in each of his final two seasons. He continues to hold the program record with 129 goals, while ranking second with 172 points. Of Manhattan's top-10 single-season goal marks, Otto accounts for four of them, including a career-high 34 as a senior in 2005. As a freshman in 2002, he helped lead the Jaspers to their lone MAAC championship, including a perfect 9-0 record during league play.