One of the most decorated softball players in Manhattan history, Yearick was a three-time All-MAAC selection as well as a three-time MAAC All-Academic honoree. She was the first Manhattan female to receive an NCAA Postgraduate Scholarship, as well as the first Lady Jasper to receive GTE National Academic All-America honors. As a freshman, she tallied 70 RBI, including a game where she belted three home runs and recorded nine RBI.