Following a four year career with the Jaspers, Creamer joins the program as an assistant coach for the 2013-14 season.

During his time as a player for Manhattan he won three individual tournament titles, one in each of his first three seasons. In his senior year he picked up two top-5 finishes including second place at the Nyack College Fall Tournament.

As a junior, Creamer won the Susquehanna Fall Invitational while leading the Jaspers to a team championship as well. He also helped the squad to tournament title at the Southern Pines Invitational. To cap off that season, he set school marks for lowest two-day non-MAAC score at the CCSU Fall Blue Devil Invitational with a combined 143. Later that year he would break the Manhattan record for best three-day MAAC Tournament score posting 220 en route to a 10th place finish.

A strong performer in the classroom at well, Creamer was named to the MAAC All-Academic Team as both a junior and senior while also being the team captain in his final campaign.